Would Your Favorite President Survive These Duke Professors’ March Madness Brackets? | News
News
INDY Week's news blog

Archives | RSS

Friday, March 9, 2018

Would Your Favorite President Survive These Duke Professors’ March Madness Brackets?

Posted by on Fri, Mar 9, 2018 at 11:01 AM

click to enlarge image001.jpg
Next week, two Duke professors—B.J. Rudell, the associate director of POLIS: The Center for Political Leadership, Innovation, and Service; and Fritz Mayer, the associate dean of the Sanford School of Public Policy—will host a five-day seminar, in which students will evaluate presidents in terms of measures of their “greatness.” It’s geared toward a very special—one might say peculiar—kind of student: the kind that is fine giving up his or her Spring Break for a weeklong class on politics that doesn’t even offer course credit.

“We’re really trying to engage students in politics in a wide variety of ways—in this case, how to think about the presidency,” Mayer explains.

This cohort, he says, came of age during President Obama’s administration, and thus their sense of what the presidency is and what the president does is shaped only by Barack Obama and Donald Trump.

And because it’s March, and there’s only one thing anyone at Duke cares about in March, Rudell thought it would be fun to put the forty-four presidents—Trump is considered number forty-five, but Grover Cleveland was elected to two nonconsecutive terms and thus is counted as numbers twenty-two and twenty-four—into March Madness-style brackets, arranged by a very loose geographic location, to enable students to consider their plusses and minuses of each president.

There are intentional matchups: George W. Bush against John Quincy Adams, the two presidents who were sons of other presidents; Franklin Pierce and James Buchanan, two feckless presidents whose failures led to the Civil War; Richard Nixon and Donald Trump, two presidents whose administrations were, well, unusual.

And that’s part of the point, Fritz says—to make students who’ve only been aware of Obama and Trump realize, from a historical perspective, what kind of anomaly Trump is.

“It’s more interesting if they come to this realization themselves that this is different than the past,” he says. 

But it’s not just about Trump; it’s about what makes a presidency “great”: Is FDR “greater” than Teddy? On what do you base that? How much of that is a factor of FDR’s inherent qualities and how much is a factor of the times in which his presidency occurred? Would Abraham Lincoln have been a great president had he not risen to power at the dawn of the Civil War?

“We like people pushing back,” Rudell says.

The class isn’t open to the public, but the March Madness contest is. Click here to download your bracket, fill it out, and email it to Rudell. For the record, here is mine (in a wonky-looking PDF, sorry). You will see that Lincoln prevailed over FDR in my final.

The professors also reached out to at least seventeen top presidential historians ask their opinions, which you can read here. You’ll find cases for greatness, or at least quasi-greatness, made for some unusual suspects: Warren G. Harding, Jimmy Carter, Chester A. Arthur, Rutherford B. Hayes, and so on.


Tags: , , , ,

Pin It

Comments

Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

INDY Week publishes all kinds of comments, but we don't publish everything.

  • Comments that are not contributing to the conversation will be removed.
  • Comments that include ad hominem attacks will also be removed.
  • Please do not copy and paste the full text of a press release.

Permitted HTML:
  • To create paragraphs in your comment, type <p> at the start of a paragraph and </p> at the end of each paragraph.
  • To create bold text, type <b>bolded text</b> (please note the closing tag, </b>).
  • To create italicized text, type <i>italicized text</i> (please note the closing tag, </i>).
  • Proper web addresses will automatically become links.

Latest in News



Twitter Activity

Comments

In the words of Donald Trump, when questioned about the future ramifications of his meeting in North Korea...

"We'll …

by Alan L. Falk on Here's What North Carolina's Representatives in Congress Think of Trump's Performance at Putin Summit (News)

I just wish some of these people who are so "russia, russia, russia", crazy. Cared about russia when they took …

by Timothy Oswald on Here's What North Carolina's Representatives in Congress Think of Trump's Performance at Putin Summit (News)

Most Read

Most Recent Comments

In the words of Donald Trump, when questioned about the future ramifications of his meeting in North Korea...

"We'll …

by Alan L. Falk on Here's What North Carolina's Representatives in Congress Think of Trump's Performance at Putin Summit (News)

I just wish some of these people who are so "russia, russia, russia", crazy. Cared about russia when they took …

by Timothy Oswald on Here's What North Carolina's Representatives in Congress Think of Trump's Performance at Putin Summit (News)

Pretty sad world we live in when a briefcase is more important than your child.

by Scott Gurtel on Pro tip: To avoid leaving child in car, put important briefcase in backseat next to less-important kid (News)

AS long as the hog industry is polluting the poor neighborhoods it is ok...according to the idiot republicans...and they are …

by Tony Dockery on The NCGA Wants to Give Hog Farms Carte Blanche to Spray Pig Crap Wherever They Want, Neighbors Be Damned (News)

I agree with the post by forourgirls. If you watch the video, you are stunned by the number of times …

by localteacher on Montessori School of Raleigh Directress Says She Was Fired for Talking to the Cops About Sexual Abuse at the School (News)

© 2018 Indy Week • 320 E. Chapel Hill St., Suite 200, Durham, NC 27701 • phone 919-286-1972 • fax 919-286-4274
RSS Feeds | Powered by Foundation