LGBT Leaders Denounce Objectively Dumb and Bad Special Session | News
News
INDY Week's news blog

Archives | RSS

Tuesday, March 22, 2016

LGBT Leaders Denounce Objectively Dumb and Bad Special Session

Posted by on Tue, Mar 22, 2016 at 6:04 PM

The day before the North Carolina legislature entered a special session to deny more forward-thinking governments the ability to provide protections for the LGBT community, leaders in that community came together to talk about their experience dealing with the exact kind of discrimination the Charlotte ordinance in question was designed to stop. 

On an ACLU and Equality NC conference call with reporters, More Light Presbyterians executive director Alex McNeill, Equality NC executive director Chris Sgro, and ACLU staff attorney Chase Strangio all talked about their personal experiences and the wider experience of Americans who deal with discrimination. All stressed that the narrative that this ordinance simply deals with bathrooms plays into the conservative legislature's argument.

At the beginning of the call, ACLU communications director Mike Meno cited the National Transgender Discrimination Survey, which found that 50 percent of North Carolina respondents reported being harassed or verbally abused in a place of public accommodation, while 8 percent reported being physically assaulted in a place of public accommodation. 

McNeill, a transgender man working to become an ordained minister, grew up in North Carolina, and while in college at "a North Carolina state school", experienced housing discrimination and had a close friend who was
click to enlarge No one knows what goes on behind closed doors. - FILE PHOTO BY ADAM DAVID KISSICK
  • File photo by Adam David Kissick
  • No one knows what goes on behind closed doors.
sucker-punched while coming out of a restroom for their perceived gender identity. He moved away to escape the discrimination, but after moving back because he thought North Carolina changed, said he was "keenly aware that I am in a state that offers no protections for me as a transgender man."

Sgro stressed that many cities and municipalities have adopted similar laws to Charlotte, and that the special session was "unique and radical". A press release from Speaker Tim Moore and Lieutenant Governor Dan Forest on Monday said they called the special session to "address a radical Charlotte City Council ordinance allowing men to share public bathrooms and locker rooms with young girls and women."

Most North Carolinians, it would appear, agree with Sgro: a PPP poll released today found that 51 percent of respondents opposed the special session, while only 25 percent supported it. Even a plurality of Republicans - 45 percent opposing to 38 percent supporting - believe that the special session is a complete waste of taxpayer money. 

Sgro said that a transgender woman friend of his, who travels a lot from Wilmington to Charlotte, often carries a cup because of her fear that she'll be denied bathroom access. He also noted that Charlotte city councilman John Autry, a supporter of the bill, received a call from a constituent threatening to "break bones" and "smash the faces in" of transgender people who used the bathroom associated with their gender identity. 

Strangio pushed back on the idea that this is an issue where both sides have equally valid points, saying it "contributes to a climate where transgender people are dehumanized." 

"We all have a responsibility to push back on false narratives and these attempts to push anti-discrimination measures as anything but what they are," he said.

ACLU of North Carolina acting executive director Sarah Preston stressed that the "bathroom" piece of the Charlotte ordinance is a small part of the whole law, as the ordinance covers all places of public accommodation (including bars or restaurants) where patrons could be refused entry based on their perceived gender identity or sexual orientation. She admitted that no one knows just how far the legislature will go, but she expects to see a "broad pre-emptive bill" that will keep other cities from enacting similar non-discrimination legislation.

It bears repeating that in the over two-hundred cities and municipalities with full LGBT non-discrimination protections (plus nineteen states and Washington, D.C.), there has never been any evidence to suggest that these laws have produced a spike in sexual assault or harassment in the bathroom. 

It wasn't all bad news for the LGBT community on Tuesday: Tennessee announced that its own version of an anti-discrimination bill had died in committee. This makes Tennessee the second diehard red state to balk at codified discrimination this year, after South Dakota governor Denis Daugaard vetoed a horrible bill earlier this month. 

Strangio said that Tennessee lawmakers were "moved" after hearing testimony from actual transgender people who deal with discrimination. "We've seen an incredible shift in some of the most conservative wings of the most conservative legislatures" once they actually talk to transgender people, he said hopefully. 

Go figure. 

Tags: , , , , ,

Pin It

Comments

Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

INDY Week publishes all kinds of comments, but we don't publish everything.

  • Comments that are not contributing to the conversation will be removed.
  • Comments that include ad hominem attacks will also be removed.
  • Please do not copy and paste the full text of a press release.

Permitted HTML:
  • To create paragraphs in your comment, type <p> at the start of a paragraph and </p> at the end of each paragraph.
  • To create bold text, type <b>bolded text</b> (please note the closing tag, </b>).
  • To create italicized text, type <i>italicized text</i> (please note the closing tag, </i>).
  • Proper web addresses will automatically become links.

Latest in News



Twitter Activity

Comments

Hello Every One, I am mrs rose kari From texas U.S.A, I quickly want to use
this medium to share …

by Excellency Mexico on “With DACA, I Feel Like I Have a Superpower”: After Trump Ends DACA, Triangle Recipients Tell Their Stories (News)

Mr. Goldsmith, please read Jennifer's post below. If you have journalistic integrity, please fix your blog as it shows up …

by Sherry D. on Mayor McFarlane Will Not Be Turned Away from Democratic Party Events, Spokesman Says (News)

Most Recent Comments

Hello Every One, I am mrs rose kari From texas U.S.A, I quickly want to use
this medium to share …

by Excellency Mexico on “With DACA, I Feel Like I Have a Superpower”: After Trump Ends DACA, Triangle Recipients Tell Their Stories (News)

Mr. Goldsmith, please read Jennifer's post below. If you have journalistic integrity, please fix your blog as it shows up …

by Sherry D. on Mayor McFarlane Will Not Be Turned Away from Democratic Party Events, Spokesman Says (News)

Look Lisa, your grandfather's story is tough. I would suggest however that he is a victim of capitalist oppression, not …

by CPF (CommiePinkoFag) on “Durham’s a Bright Light for Our Movement”: After Their Cases Were Continued Until November, Defend Durham Activists Took a Victory Lap (News)

Apparently we must hope that the N&O doesn't follow through on this trend by deciding that they will cover legislative …

by khoragos on The N&O’s Performing Arts Correspondent Says the Paper Is Cutting Back on Performing Arts Reviews (News)

Cancelling the parade affects all people. I usually went just for the parade, not the night events. Parents take their …

by Aiden on Carolina Jews for Justice Says NC Pride Schedule Fix Isn't Enough (News)

© 2017 Indy Week • 320 E. Chapel Hill St., Suite 200, Durham, NC 27701 • phone 919-286-1972 • fax 919-286-4274
RSS Feeds | Powered by Foundation