Court upholds Durham woman's conviction for fatally stabbing dog | News
News
INDY Week's news blog

Archives | RSS

Wednesday, December 3, 2014

Court upholds Durham woman's conviction for fatally stabbing dog

Posted by on Wed, Dec 3, 2014 at 8:41 AM

Yesterday the North Carolina Court of Appeals published a unanimous opinion affirming a lower court's conviction of a Durham woman who stabbed her dog to death after it bit her finger.

Nesta Gerberding, who was convicted for felonious animal cruelty and given probation, had claimed she was justified in the killing because the pit bull, Tank, was vicious, and she wanted to protect her family and the people an animals in the neighborhood.

She also contended that during her trial last year, the judge offered improper jury instructions by using non-applicable hypothetical examples of crime justifications that had nothing to do with animal cruelty, and prejudiced the jury by suggesting she acted with malice, which is the factor that separates felonious animal cruelty from misdemeanor animal cruelty.

In its opinion yesterday, the appellate court disagreed with Gerberding's first argument. Gerberding, the judges argued, citing case law, "ignores the rule of law that the trial judge is 'not required to parrot the instructions or to become a mere judicial phonograph for recording the exact and identical words of counsel.' "

On Gerberding's second point — that the judge prejudiced the jury by suggesting Gerberding acted with malice — the judges split. 

During jury deliberations during Gerberding's trial, the jury asked the judge a question: were the four elements of malice—namely hatred, ill will, spite and intent—all necessary for a felony conviction? The judge responded that any one of those elements, standing alone, could satisfy the definition of malice. Gerberding argued that intent, standing alone, should not automatically denote malice. "Just because I killed the animal doesn't mean I did it with ill will," she said in an interview earlier this year.

Judges Rick Elmore and Wanda Bryant disagreed with Gerding, opining that the jury was free to convict Gerberding for felony or misdemeanor animal cruelty. But in a separate opinion, Judge Sam Ervin sided with Gerberding on this point. However, Ervin concluded that the trial judge's error didn't rise to the level to necessitate relief from Gerberding's conviction.

The case highlights a rise in animal cruelty felony charges in the state. In 2013, 191 North Carolinians were charged with felonies, more than twice the number from a decade ago.


Pin It

Comments

Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

INDY Week publishes all kinds of comments, but we don't publish everything.

  • Comments that are not contributing to the conversation will be removed.
  • Comments that include ad hominem attacks will also be removed.
  • Please do not copy and paste the full text of a press release.

Permitted HTML:
  • To create paragraphs in your comment, type <p> at the start of a paragraph and </p> at the end of each paragraph.
  • To create bold text, type <b>bolded text</b> (please note the closing tag, </b>).
  • To create italicized text, type <i>italicized text</i> (please note the closing tag, </i>).
  • Proper web addresses will automatically become links.

Latest in News



Twitter Activity

Comments

Sarah, Beg to differ. HT

http://www.womennc.org/un-csw-fellowship/2…

WomenNC proudly announces its 2017-18 CSW Fellows!

We …

by Harris Tweed on Women of Color Are "Particularly Burdened" by Gentrification in Durham (News)

Harris Tweed, the Capstone program is a UNC program. Thanks for reading!

https://publicpolicy.unc.edu/academics/exp…

by swillets on Women of Color Are "Particularly Burdened" by Gentrification in Durham (News)

Most Recent Comments

Sarah, Beg to differ. HT

http://www.womennc.org/un-csw-fellowship/2…

WomenNC proudly announces its 2017-18 CSW Fellows!

We …

by Harris Tweed on Women of Color Are "Particularly Burdened" by Gentrification in Durham (News)

Harris Tweed, the Capstone program is a UNC program. Thanks for reading!

https://publicpolicy.unc.edu/academics/exp…

by swillets on Women of Color Are "Particularly Burdened" by Gentrification in Durham (News)

Sounds like hitting the accelerator on gentrification and push out. More hand outs for developers.

by M 1 on The Opportunity Zone Tax Incentive Is Supposed to Help Distressed Areas. See Which Parts of Durham Are Up for It. (News)

Capstone Fellows are part of http://WomenNC.org, a 501c3 non-profit. They do not appear to be UNC Fellowships …

by Harris Tweed on Women of Color Are "Particularly Burdened" by Gentrification in Durham (News)

© 2018 Indy Week • 320 E. Chapel Hill St., Suite 200, Durham, NC 27701 • phone 919-286-1972 • fax 919-286-4274
RSS Feeds | Powered by Foundation