The District Attorney Declines to Prosecute the Cop Who Killed Frank Clark, But Residents of McDougald Terrace Still Doubt the Official Narrative | Durham County | Indy Week
Pin It

The District Attorney Declines to Prosecute the Cop Who Killed Frank Clark, But Residents of McDougald Terrace Still Doubt the Official Narrative 

Dave Hall, a lawyer for the Clark family, conducts a press conference on November 30.

Photo by Alex Boerner

Dave Hall, a lawyer for the Clark family, conducts a press conference on November 30.

After our exhaustive review, I have found that probable cause does not exist to charge a crime in the shooting death of Frank Nathaniel Clark. —Roger Echols, Durham County district attorney, March 20, 2017

They said District Attorney Roger Echols's report on the officer-involved killing of thirty-four-year-old Frank Clark "didn't add up" and disputed claims that "Scooter Bug," as he was known, pointed a weapon or fired at Master Officer Charles Barkley before Barkley fatally shot him.

But they also didn't want to go on the record, because they're certain, as one put it, "Barkely's gonna be back on this block." And that, they said, scares them.

Six of the two dozen McDougald Terrace residents who spoke to the INDY after Clark's death on November 22 and spoke again on background last week—the others either declined to be interviewed or could not be located—argued that something is off about the district attorney's statement on Clark's killing, which draws on the State Bureau of Investigation's report (which has not been released to the public). That version of events, they point out, even seems to contradict the Durham Police Department's initial five-day report on the shooting, which never mentions that Clark fired two shots at the officers or pointed a gun at Barkley, as Echols's statement claims.

They also agreed that, should Barkley, Officer Monte Southerland, and Officer Christopher Goss make it out of the DPD's ongoing internal investigation unscathed, Clark's death won't be the last tragedy to unfold in the city's low-income, mostly African-American neighborhoods.

"We knew they wasn't gonna charge [Barkley]," a college-age woman told the INDY. "But you watch. Somethin' gonna happen. Shit. Somethin' happened way before that man killed Scooter Bug. We don't want these cops back out here. You hear me, [police chief] C.J. [Davis]? You done better fix this shit."

According to the DPD's five-day report—the only official document the department has released on the incident—Barkley, Southerland, and Goss did not show up to McDougald Terrace in response to a 911 call or any report of a crime in progress. The three, all members of the Violent Incident Response Team, were "patrolling the area" when they "saw a man near Building 60" and decided to "speak with him." But Echols said Clark was trespassing, which gave officers probable cause to "pat him down."

According to Echols, a struggle ensued, a shot was fired, and "when the officers were able to focus on Mr. Clark, he had a handgun drawn and pointed towards Officer Barkley."

That, Echols concluded, gave Barkley justification to fire.

"That's some bullshit right there," a middle-aged woman who says she saw the incident told the INDY. "Scooter Bug wasn't pointing no gun. That's a lie. I don't care what they say. That's a motherfuckin' lie. Maybe he had a gun. Maybe he didn't. But I saw it. I saw it. And he was runnin', not pointin' no gun."

The twenty-foot distance between the location of the shell casings and Clark's body, as well as the autopsy published December 30 by the Office of the Chief Medical Examiner—which revealed that both shots, one that shattered his femur and another that penetrated his skull, entered the back of Clark's body—seem to corroborate eyewitness accounts previously published in the INDY that Clark was fleeing the officers when he was shot.

Echols noted the two shots in his statement and acknowledged that they were the cause of death. But beyond that, he made little mention of the medical examiner's findings. While he noted the shell casings, he did not examine their proximity to the victim. Nor did he address whether Clark was fleeing when he was shot.

Comments

Showing 1-1 of 1

Add a comment

 
Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-1 of 1

Add a comment

INDY Week publishes all kinds of comments, but we don't publish everything.

  • Comments that are not contributing to the conversation will be removed.
  • Comments that include ad hominem attacks will also be removed.
  • Please do not copy and paste the full text of a press release.

Permitted HTML:
  • To create paragraphs in your comment, type <p> at the start of a paragraph and </p> at the end of each paragraph.
  • To create bold text, type <b>bolded text</b> (please note the closing tag, </b>).
  • To create italicized text, type <i>italicized text</i> (please note the closing tag, </i>).
  • Proper web addresses will automatically become links.

Latest in Durham County



Twitter Activity

Comments

Sounds like vigilantism to me. But at least it should take any supporter out of consideration for Steve Schewel's seat. …

by MJKopechne on Will the Felony Charges Against Defend Durham Demonstrators Be Dropped? (Durham County)

People's tribunal?

by John Trololo on Will the Felony Charges Against Defend Durham Demonstrators Be Dropped? (Durham County)

Most Recent Comments

Sounds like vigilantism to me. But at least it should take any supporter out of consideration for Steve Schewel's seat. …

by MJKopechne on Will the Felony Charges Against Defend Durham Demonstrators Be Dropped? (Durham County)

People's tribunal?

by John Trololo on Will the Felony Charges Against Defend Durham Demonstrators Be Dropped? (Durham County)

White supremacists call this progress, the klan would be proud of black families being pushed out of durham.

by lamer99 on For Two Decades, Durham’s East End Neighborhood Hosted Horseshoe Matches With No Complaints. Then the Developers Came. (Durham County)

What happens with respect to Councilwoman Cole-McFadden? Would she be able to vote, or is it the newly elected council …

by arrbeejay on What Happens to Steve Schewel’s Council Seat if He Becomes Mayor? (Durham County)

Durham and Duke need to finally follow Chapel Hill/UNC's lead and offer fare-free service for all.

by walty on With Duke University Pulling Its Funding, What’s the Future of the Bull City Connector? (Durham County)

© 2017 Indy Week • 320 E. Chapel Hill St., Suite 200, Durham, NC 27701 • phone 919-286-1972 • fax 919-286-4274
RSS Feeds | Powered by Foundation