How Much Is a Confederate Monument Worth? | Durham County | Indy Week
Pin It

How Much Is a Confederate Monument Worth? 

click to enlarge confederate_monument_down.jpg

Photo by Sarah Willets

Four days after demonstrators tore down a Confederate monument in downtown Durham in August, District Attorney Roger Echols announced he would seek "a just resolution" for those charged with the statue's toppling. That resolution would take into account "the pain in Durham and the nation," as well as an assessment of the property damage, which he asked county manager Wendell Davis and the board of commissioners to estimate.

That estimate, county officials discovered, wasn't easy to come by. Is the now-crumpled statue worth the modern equivalent of the $5,000 commissioners paid to erect it in 1923? Is the value whatever it would cost to replace the metal figure of a solider? Is this divisive object worth anything in a city always striving to be more inclusive?

After a closed session last Monday, county commissioners unanimously approved a letter to Echols attempting to reconcile the monetary value of the object with the social context surrounding it.

"In many ways, it's very subjective, so that was really the challenge," chairwoman Wendy Jacobs told the INDY. "I think everyone on our board felt really strongly that financial value had to be in the context of the value to our community." Jacobs says commissioners received thousands of emails about the issue, most from people who felt the statue had little or negative value.

In 2017 dollars, Davis told commissioners Monday, the statue, including the still-standing base, was worth just over $71,000. Staff members figured the statue itself accounts for about a third of that value. Informal bids to replace the statue came in at about $28,000.

However, the board adds in the letter, the statue has "no moral value for our community."

"Many people feel that the statue has been a harsh reminder of racial discrimination, oppression, pain and suffering," the letter reads. "We understand some people in our community feel that the statue has historical, cultural or personal value to them and we also recognize that to many people in our community, the statue has little or even negative value."

Commissioner Heidi Carter objected to including the word "moral." She said she would have preferred a stronger statement, but that it was important for the board to get behind a unified message.

"The most important part for me, however, is the worth to our community, and that's the kind of value I really wanted us to hit a little harder. I feel like we're skirting it a little," she said during the meeting. "... We don't have to say moral value—it's value. I wish we felt like we could be strong enough to just come out with 'value.'"

Carter says she thought more of the process should have been public, as opposed to taking place in a closed session. "I absolutely thought any discussion of the wording of that letter needed to be public," she says, adding, "I think that it was reasonable to go into closed session to discuss the actual general statute that limits what we can do with public monuments."

Jacobs says the board was operating in unfamiliar legal territory, first by interpreting the untested 2015 state law protecting Confederate monuments, and second by providing information that would be taken under advisement by a prosecutor.

The board left with plans to continue discussion of all of Durham's memorials, monuments, and historical honors.

"The toppling of that statue toppled kind of the veil of peace to some degree over the community and unleashed concerns that some people probably carry around inside them," said Commissioner Ellen Reckhow. "I think this is the beginning of probably what will be much more extensive discussion about the remainder of that monument."

Comments (8)

Showing 1-8 of 8

Add a comment

 
Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-8 of 8

Add a comment

INDY Week publishes all kinds of comments, but we don't publish everything.

  • Comments that are not contributing to the conversation will be removed.
  • Comments that include ad hominem attacks will also be removed.
  • Please do not copy and paste the full text of a press release.

Permitted HTML:
  • To create paragraphs in your comment, type <p> at the start of a paragraph and </p> at the end of each paragraph.
  • To create bold text, type <b>bolded text</b> (please note the closing tag, </b>).
  • To create italicized text, type <i>italicized text</i> (please note the closing tag, </i>).
  • Proper web addresses will automatically become links.

Latest in Durham County



Twitter Activity

Comments

As politics, and the judiciary in particular , become more ideological, how does expertise now weigh in the balance?

by Solomon Burnette on Judicial Candidates Used to Eschew Ideology. Not This Year. Not in Durham. (Durham County)

- in response to Mike Moore's last question:
documented below, by M1; what?
you think the cops, who …

by Chris Tiffany on The Durham Jail Charges Detainees Extra for Commissary Items, Then Uses That Money to Pay for Things Like Blankets and Sheets (Durham County)

Most Recent Comments

As politics, and the judiciary in particular , become more ideological, how does expertise now weigh in the balance?

by Solomon Burnette on Judicial Candidates Used to Eschew Ideology. Not This Year. Not in Durham. (Durham County)

- in response to Mike Moore's last question:
documented below, by M1; what?
you think the cops, who …

by Chris Tiffany on The Durham Jail Charges Detainees Extra for Commissary Items, Then Uses That Money to Pay for Things Like Blankets and Sheets (Durham County)

And other than your own head, where was this story of the group of innocent men documented? Jail is an …

by Mike Moore on The Durham Jail Charges Detainees Extra for Commissary Items, Then Uses That Money to Pay for Things Like Blankets and Sheets (Durham County)

The other week, I witnessed the Durham police department unlawfully arrest a group of young black men with absolutely no …

by M 1 on The Durham Jail Charges Detainees Extra for Commissary Items, Then Uses That Money to Pay for Things Like Blankets and Sheets (Durham County)

These people are already being a burden on the rest of us by being engaging in behaviours that put them …

by Mike Moore on The Durham Jail Charges Detainees Extra for Commissary Items, Then Uses That Money to Pay for Things Like Blankets and Sheets (Durham County)

© 2018 Indy Week • 320 E. Chapel Hill St., Suite 200, Durham, NC 27701 • phone 919-286-1972 • fax 919-286-4274
RSS Feeds | Powered by Foundation