Durham prepared foods tax | Our Endorsements | Indy Week
Pin It

Durham prepared foods tax 

The presidential race at top of the ballot is attracting the most attention, but a pressing issue at the bottom of the ballot is eliciting sharp opinions from Durham County voters.

This fall, the prepared foods tax, also known as the meals tax, is up for a public vote. If passed, a 1 percent tax—one penny for every dollar spent—would be placed on prepared foods. This includes grocery deli items and restaurant and fast-food meals. It does not include meals at campus dining halls.

The estimated $5 million in annual revenue would go toward dozens of cultural, recreation, beautification and workforce development projects, many of which have been back-burnered for years. These include an expansion of the Hayti Heritage Center, a rehab of the Durham Civic Center, and the Parrish Street museum that would celebrate the city's historic "Black Wall Street." The money would help fund the creation and maintenance of trails, including at West Point on the Eno and New Hope Preserve. Some funding would also be allocated for job training programs in the hospitality industry at Durham Technical Community College and N.C. Central University.

While this is a difficult time to levy another tax—some would say there is no good time to do so—1 percent is a small price to pay for much-needed cultural and recreational amenities that would add to residents' quality of life. We recommend a vote FOR the 1 percent prepared foods tax.

Let's say lunch at McDonald's comes to $5, without any taxes. There is a 6.75 percent sales tax on that amount—34 cents. Add the 1 percent—five cents—for the prepared meals tax, and the total is $5.39. Without the prepared meals tax it would have been $5.34.

Proponents estimate 60 percent of the tax burden would be borne by commuters and visitors. And the tax is not unprecedented: Wake County and the Town of Hillsborough already have a prepared meals tax, passed by their respective elected officials, not by voters.

In those areas, we've heard from opponents who acknowledge the levy has had no effect on business: neither good, from an increase in tourism because of marketing dollars generated by the tax, or bad, because of the small increase to their customers' tab. However, restaurant owners are rightfully concerned about any addition to their rising food costs.

We do not agree with the argument that the tax unfairly burdens low-income families. More punitive would be a property tax hike, which is almost certain, but it could be even higher if Durham relies on that levy to pay not only for some of these projects, but also for other necessities such as schools, sewer service and transportation. A property tax hike is more pervasive than a meals tax: It not only hurts property owners (including restaurateurs) at a particularly vulnerable time, but also renters, who will bear some of the burden as the expense is passed on to them.

There are social justice benefits to the meals tax: For example, the proposed Pearsontown Trail would run from N.C. Central to Hayti; that area has no urban trails and has been all but forgotten. Many of the proposed amenities, especially the recreational projects, are free and can be enjoyed by everyone, regardless of income.

Successful, vibrant cities not only have business, industry and higher education, but also an excellent quality of life. Culture and recreation are part of that: Arts and music can inspire everyone and should not be the domain of the privileged. Nature trails and open space should not be reserved for only the wealthy neighborhoods; they belong in the inner city as well.

This brings us to our final points: If voters pass the tax, it is essential that the cultural and recreational amenities remain affordable; many of them should be free. Secondly, it is essential that Durham citizens have oversight and input on the funding. If we are to trust our elected officials with this money, it is incumbent on them to allocate it fairly, without political pressure from the well-connected, so that these projects—and their promise—benefit all of Durham.

Comments (12)

Showing 1-12 of 12

Add a comment

 
Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-12 of 12

Add a comment

INDY Week publishes all kinds of comments, but we don't publish everything.

  • Comments that are not contributing to the conversation will be removed.
  • Comments that include ad hominem attacks will also be removed.
  • Please do not copy and paste the full text of a press release.

Permitted HTML:
  • To create paragraphs in your comment, type <p> at the start of a paragraph and </p> at the end of each paragraph.
  • To create bold text, type <b>bolded text</b> (please note the closing tag, </b>).
  • To create italicized text, type <i>italicized text</i> (please note the closing tag, </i>).
  • Proper web addresses will automatically become links.

Latest in Our Endorsements



Twitter Activity

Comments

Anyone who has read my op-eds that have run in newspaper across the country, would know I do not support …

by Frank Hyman on The INDY Endorses Mark-Anthony Middleton for Durham City Council Ward 2 (Our Endorsements)

I'm shocked that Allen Buansi wasn't endorsed. I would urge readers to read up on him.

by Sean Bickford on The INDY Endorses Ed Harrison, Hongbin Gu, Rachel Schaevitz, and Karen Stegman for Chapel Hill Town Council (Our Endorsements)

Most Read

No recently-read stories.

Visit the archives…

Most Recent Comments

Anyone who has read my op-eds that have run in newspaper across the country, would know I do not support …

by Frank Hyman on The INDY Endorses Mark-Anthony Middleton for Durham City Council Ward 2 (Our Endorsements)

I'm shocked that Allen Buansi wasn't endorsed. I would urge readers to read up on him.

by Sean Bickford on The INDY Endorses Ed Harrison, Hongbin Gu, Rachel Schaevitz, and Karen Stegman for Chapel Hill Town Council (Our Endorsements)

How did the Indy get this so wrong? Middleton is the candidate that made the statement you are accusing Rooks …

by green bean on In Durham’s Ward 2, the INDY Endorses Mark-Anthony Middleton for City Council (Our Endorsements)

I urge your readers to look at Allen Buansi's credentials, which are readily found on line. He has a long, …

by Jennifer Van Vickle on The INDY Endorses Ed Harrison, Hongbin Gu, Rachel Schaevitz, and Karen Stegman for Chapel Hill Town Council (Our Endorsements)

@Durham451 @Frank

Have you been to the communities that are suffering? Would you like to come by? If you …

by stylze4u on In Durham’s Ward 2, the INDY Endorses Mark-Anthony Middleton for City Council (Our Endorsements)

© 2017 Indy Week • 320 E. Chapel Hill St., Suite 200, Durham, NC 27701 • phone 919-286-1972 • fax 919-286-4274
RSS Feeds | Powered by Foundation