Durham County Candidates Ask for an Election Do-Over | Triangulator | Indy Week
Pin It

Durham County Candidates Ask for an Election Do-Over 

Durham County Board of Elections

File photo by D.L. Anderson

Durham County Board of Elections

Few would argue that the Durham County Board of Elections botched the March primary. Voters across the county reported having to wait in line for several hours to cast their votes. Then, on May 5, the DCBOE announced that the State Board of Elections would be investigating a discrepancy discovered during an internal audit of the primary. Apparently, some provisional ballots—votes cast when there is a question about the validity of the voter's eligibility—were mishandled by staff.

Three losing candidates in the Durham County commissioners' race—Elaine Hyman, Michael Page, and Fred Foster Jr.—formally protested the results. On Friday, the DCBOE held an emergency meeting to discuss these protests. It ended, somewhat improbably, with the DCBOE declaring that "it would not be unreasonable for the State Board of Elections to consider ordering a new primary for Durham County Board of Commissioners to address the public's concerns."

A do-over primary would make sense, of course, if the math indicated that the mishandling of the ballots could have affected the outcome. But, as the state and county boards have maintained, that is not the case. There are 759 potential votes up for grabs in the retallying of the county commission race. But the top vote-getting loser, Chairman Michael Page, trailed the last-place winner, newcomer James Hill, by over one thousand votes. Hyman and Foster are even further behind.

Hill, not surprisingly, opposes the idea of re-do. "There is going to be minuscule voter turnout," Hill says—especially since many students at Duke and N.C. Central would be on break during a summer primary. Simply put, more people would be disenfranchised by a low-turnout do-over than had their March ballots mishandled.

And in addition to drawing fewer voters, special elections also cost a bunch of money. (The DCBOE declined to guess how much, since it's unclear whether the re-do will be a standalone or be lumped in with an already-scheduled election.) That's hard to justify, given that there's no evidence suggesting the March results weren't legitimate.

So why do it? Hyman, who supports a new primary, says it's about restoring confidence in the system.

"When those of us who are candidates step out of that arena and run for public office and do not win, we still want to know the standing," Hyman says. "Was I number seven, was I number eight, was I number six, or was I number five?"

Ultimately, however, the decision lies with the SBOE, which was expected to render a decision on Tuesday afternoon, after the INDY went to press.

triangulator@indyweek.com

Comments

Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

INDY Week publishes all kinds of comments, but we don't publish everything.

  • Comments that are not contributing to the conversation will be removed.
  • Comments that include ad hominem attacks will also be removed.
  • Please do not copy and paste the full text of a press release.

Permitted HTML:
  • To create paragraphs in your comment, type <p> at the start of a paragraph and </p> at the end of each paragraph.
  • To create bold text, type <b>bolded text</b> (please note the closing tag, </b>).
  • To create italicized text, type <i>italicized text</i> (please note the closing tag, </i>).
  • Proper web addresses will automatically become links.

Latest in Triangulator



Twitter Activity

Comments

I'd take the 800 square foot studio for $500 a month, actually. As long as my neighbors are nice and …

by ammi on Capitol Broadcasting Wants Community Input on Its American Tobacco Campus Expansion. By God We're Going to Give It to Them. (Triangulator)

I want to acknowledge how lucky Durham is to have such incredible leaders in the community as provided by the …

by duh on Capitol Broadcasting Wants Community Input on Its American Tobacco Campus Expansion. By God We're Going to Give It to Them. (Triangulator)

Most Recent Comments

I'd take the 800 square foot studio for $500 a month, actually. As long as my neighbors are nice and …

by ammi on Capitol Broadcasting Wants Community Input on Its American Tobacco Campus Expansion. By God We're Going to Give It to Them. (Triangulator)

I want to acknowledge how lucky Durham is to have such incredible leaders in the community as provided by the …

by duh on Capitol Broadcasting Wants Community Input on Its American Tobacco Campus Expansion. By God We're Going to Give It to Them. (Triangulator)

It's well and good for elected officials to state support for CACs after they voted May 2 to approve a …

by George Farthing on McFarlane’s Attempt to Overhaul CACs Might Be a Big Issue in Raleigh’s Mayor’s Race (Triangulator)

I don't understand the Perry Woods response. To say that Nancy McFarlane hasn't attended to basic concerns of the public …

by ct on McFarlane’s Attempt to Overhaul CACs Might Be a Big Issue in Raleigh’s Mayor’s Race (Triangulator)

Respectfully, Mr. Goldsmith, you should learn to read the CAFR before publishing things that are NOT FACTUAL. What you've decided …

by Trixsie M on Wake County Found an Extra $3 Million. Who Decides How to Spend It—Commissioners or Bureaucrats? (Triangulator)

© 2017 Indy Week • 320 E. Chapel Hill St., Suite 200, Durham, NC 27701 • phone 919-286-1972 • fax 919-286-4274
RSS Feeds | Powered by Foundation