Duke’s Adjunct Faculty Uprising Is Just What Higher Ed Needs | Durham County | Indy Week
Pin It

Duke’s Adjunct Faculty Uprising Is Just What Higher Ed Needs 

Duke University’s adjunct faculty members celebrate a vote to join the SEIU last Monday.

Photo by Alex Boerner

Duke University’s adjunct faculty members celebrate a vote to join the SEIU last Monday.

The culmination of the months-long campaign to organize a faculty union at Duke University came far from the campus, in the nondescript offices of the National Labor Relations Board in Winston-Salem. It was, for anyone who cares about the state of American universities, a sobering scene.

This was the counting of mailed-in ballots to determine if 296 nontenured, nonrank faculty members at Duke had chosen to join the Service Employees International Union.

As the two sides huddled around a hearing room table—a half-dozen Duke officials and their lawyers on one end, a dozen faculty members, their lawyers, and organizers from the union on the other—NLRB officer Ingrid Jenkins directed the tedious process: first, determine whether each envelope received was from an eligible person; second, open and insert the ballot into a cardboard box to preserve anonymity; third, read each ballot aloud.

Yes. No. Yes. Yes.

In the two hours it took to complete this task, it was clear that this wasn't Duke and a part of its faculty tilting amicably. Rather, it was "the company" and "the union"—Jenkins's terms—staring across a great divide.

The outcome, on March 18, was a lopsided win for the union, 179–24, with thirteen ballots set aside because of contested eligibility.

Why did I find the clash so jarring? Because it burst my ideal of what university governance should be, with faculty at the center and the administration supporting them. For that matter, it was jarring to realize that an eclectic group of scholars, individualists for whom the uniformity of a union seemed an odd fit, wanted the SEIU nonetheless.

But there it was. The modern university isn't governed by its faculty, though in my memory administrators were drawn from the faculty, and they respected the tradition that a university was its faculty and students.

Its tenured faculty, anyway. But then, most faculty members had tenure.

Today, though, universities are run like a business—they've been "corporatized," critics say, and chase the almighty buck—while a majority of faculty members lack the protection of tenure or any hope of getting it. Instead, their employment is "contingent," dependent on fixed-term contracts that are typically one to three years long but may be semester to semester—and are often part-time. Those without tenure are constrained in their ability to challenge university policy. They're treated as workers who may or may not be retained.

Rann Bar-On is a Duke mathematics instructor with a contract. "We are workers," Bar-On told me after the votes were counted. "Especially those of us who focus on teaching, as I do." As opposed to doing research, he meant. "I do not consider myself as any different from workers in other industries," Bar-On added. "Because the university does not."

Across the country, contingent faculty workers are banding together: according to The Wall Street Journal, union drives have succeeded at seventy colleges and universities in the last three years.

Duke stands out, however, as a first in the South and, according to the Journal, "the first new private sector faculty union in a right-to-work state in decades."

The question ahead is whether unions can help stem the impacts of corporatization and reassert the centrality of teaching, learning, and inquiry on American campuses. Will unions play the role that tenured faculty once did to safeguard academic freedom? And, in North Carolina, will Duke's union spark an uprising on other campuses, in particular across a University of North Carolina system under threat from forces corporate and political?

Comments (6)

Showing 1-6 of 6

Add a comment

 
Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-6 of 6

Add a comment

INDY Week publishes all kinds of comments, but we don't publish everything.

  • Comments that are not contributing to the conversation will be removed.
  • Comments that include ad hominem attacks will also be removed.
  • Please do not copy and paste the full text of a press release.

Permitted HTML:
  • To create paragraphs in your comment, type <p> at the start of a paragraph and </p> at the end of each paragraph.
  • To create bold text, type <b>bolded text</b> (please note the closing tag, </b>).
  • To create italicized text, type <i>italicized text</i> (please note the closing tag, </i>).
  • Proper web addresses will automatically become links.

Latest in Durham County



Twitter Activity

Comments

As politics, and the judiciary in particular , become more ideological, how does expertise now weigh in the balance?

by Solomon Burnette on Judicial Candidates Used to Eschew Ideology. Not This Year. Not in Durham. (Durham County)

- in response to Mike Moore's last question:
documented below, by M1; what?
you think the cops, who …

by Chris Tiffany on The Durham Jail Charges Detainees Extra for Commissary Items, Then Uses That Money to Pay for Things Like Blankets and Sheets (Durham County)

Most Read

Most Recent Comments

As politics, and the judiciary in particular , become more ideological, how does expertise now weigh in the balance?

by Solomon Burnette on Judicial Candidates Used to Eschew Ideology. Not This Year. Not in Durham. (Durham County)

- in response to Mike Moore's last question:
documented below, by M1; what?
you think the cops, who …

by Chris Tiffany on The Durham Jail Charges Detainees Extra for Commissary Items, Then Uses That Money to Pay for Things Like Blankets and Sheets (Durham County)

And other than your own head, where was this story of the group of innocent men documented? Jail is an …

by Mike Moore on The Durham Jail Charges Detainees Extra for Commissary Items, Then Uses That Money to Pay for Things Like Blankets and Sheets (Durham County)

The other week, I witnessed the Durham police department unlawfully arrest a group of young black men with absolutely no …

by M 1 on The Durham Jail Charges Detainees Extra for Commissary Items, Then Uses That Money to Pay for Things Like Blankets and Sheets (Durham County)

These people are already being a burden on the rest of us by being engaging in behaviours that put them …

by Mike Moore on The Durham Jail Charges Detainees Extra for Commissary Items, Then Uses That Money to Pay for Things Like Blankets and Sheets (Durham County)

© 2018 Indy Week • 320 E. Chapel Hill St., Suite 200, Durham, NC 27701 • phone 919-286-1972 • fax 919-286-4274
RSS Feeds | Powered by Foundation