Big bucks lost on Durham trash trucks | Public Records Requests | Indy Week
Pin It

Big bucks lost on Durham trash trucks 

Ever experience that moment of panic when you realize you've mail-ordered the wrong waffle maker or pair of golf shoes? In most scenarios, you're out only the $10 shipping charge to send them back.

But if you're the City of Durham, a mistake like this costs much more, such as the $124,000 the city lost on two new trucks erroneously purchased by the solid waste department for removing residents' bulky items or storm debris.

The city couldn't unload the 2006 Chevy trucks on other nearby municipalities or through an online auction. So instead of scooping up bulky items and downed tree limbs over the past four years, the trucks sat parked, depreciating rapidly, until they were recently auctioned for $29,000 apiece—32 percent of the original price. Each truck had fewer than 1,000 miles on it.

A 68 percent-off sale! A great deal for the buyer, Chapman's Automotive in Hillsborough, which snapped up the trucks at the auction. A bad deal for Durham's taxpayers, who don't like to see government officials make mistakes with their money, a scarce commodity these days.

It turns out the trucks—models equipped with knuckle-boom cranes that hoist large objects to be hauled to the county dump—weren't the exact type of vehicle the solid waste department needed. The design was inefficient for a single driver to pick up residents' bulky trash, said Deputy City Manager Ted Voorhees.

A city employee would have to drive to a resident's house, get out of the driver's seat and climb up several feet into a separate cab to operate the crane and then lower himself or herself back into the driver's seat once the job was done. Plus, Voorhees said, there was less than optimum visibility from the crane operator's cab. 'Nuff said. Not being able to see where you're swinging a large crane = danger.

Although the $124,000 loss is less than 1 percent of the solid waste department's $18.4 million operating budget this year, extra money is always useful. The loss would have paid for two years of solid waste's code-enforcement program, which has three full-time positions.

Who is accountable? Alfred Davis, a previous solid waste department supervisor, purchased the trucks. He left the city years ago to become the city manager of Tuskeegee, Ala. Back then, Voorhees said, Davis wasn't required to consult a chain of command to spend nearly $180,000 on the trucks. Davis didn't return a call seeking comment.

"This is a poor purchase," Voorhees said. It wasn't well thought-out and didn't meet the goals it was intended to achieve, he stated. Had Davis solicited input from other managers or departments, it could have been avoided, Voorhees said.

The year after Davis bought the trucks, the City Council enacted a Fleet Replacement Program to manage and monitor the proper maintenance and replacement of the 2,100-plus vehicles the city uses. Any purchases now have to go through a lot of checkpoints, requiring input from the city's fleet and financial managers.

In other words, there shouldn't be any more $124,000 mistakes, Voorhees said.

Editor's Note: This column is based on public records requests to local, state and federal agencies. Are you curious? We'll submit your public records requests. Send them to editors@indyweek.com.

Comments

Showing 1-1 of 1

Add a comment

 
Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-1 of 1

Add a comment

INDY Week publishes all kinds of comments, but we don't publish everything.

  • Comments that are not contributing to the conversation will be removed.
  • Comments that include ad hominem attacks will also be removed.
  • Please do not copy and paste the full text of a press release.

Permitted HTML:
  • To create paragraphs in your comment, type <p> at the start of a paragraph and </p> at the end of each paragraph.
  • To create bold text, type <b>bolded text</b> (please note the closing tag, </b>).
  • To create italicized text, type <i>italicized text</i> (please note the closing tag, </i>).
  • Proper web addresses will automatically become links.

Latest in Public Records Requests

  • In public school, blacks, Hispanics suspended at higher rates than whites

    In public school, blacks, Hispanics suspended at higher rates than whites

    Although the number of suspensions has declined in many Triangle school districts in the last 10 years, the racial disparities among suspension rates remain the same, according to North Carolina's Annual Study of Suspensions and Expulsions.
    • Apr 25, 2012
  • Breaking bad in North Carolina

    Breaking bad in North Carolina

    More than half of N.C.'s counties recorded at least one bust for a methamphetamine lab in 2011. Law enforcement officials discovered 344 labs throughout the state last year.
    • Feb 8, 2012
  • How many cases of justifiable homicide are there each year?

    How many cases of justifiable homicide are there each year?

    It's a question we asked in light of the proposed expansion of the so-called Castle Doctrine, which lays out the circumstances under which you can kill someone in self-defense.
    • Mar 9, 2011
  • More »


Twitter Activity

Comments

And how many criminals got shot, but didn't die? How many got caught at gun point until the police arrived? …

by Túlélő Tmib on How many cases of justifiable homicide are there each year? (Public Records Requests)

"I do not claim to be an expert on the subject,but I think I would prefer some dust and smoke …

by selleugra on Fact-checking UNC's coal claims (Public Records Requests)

Most Recent Comments

And how many criminals got shot, but didn't die? How many got caught at gun point until the police arrived? …

by Túlélő Tmib on How many cases of justifiable homicide are there each year? (Public Records Requests)

"I do not claim to be an expert on the subject,but I think I would prefer some dust and smoke …

by selleugra on Fact-checking UNC's coal claims (Public Records Requests)

Well,where to start is mind numbing. Red River Coal provides safe, quality employment and benefits for numerous families in Southwest …

by K13C on Fact-checking UNC's coal claims (Public Records Requests)

This is so sad the things I am reading I know for sure that there are some mental ill people …

by sweetbrnback01 on In public school, blacks, Hispanics suspended at higher rates than whites (Public Records Requests)

The intention of this article was not to race bait, it is to inform. I hope the simple use of …

by Tiara Hodges on In public school, blacks, Hispanics suspended at higher rates than whites (Public Records Requests)

© 2017 Indy Week • 320 E. Chapel Hill St., Suite 200, Durham, NC 27701 • phone 919-286-1972 • fax 919-286-4274
RSS Feeds | Powered by Foundation