Wednesday, November 18, 2009
Memo: Medlin finds Jordan Lake protest petition valid
A memo sent from Durham planning Director Steve Medlin to County Manager Mike Ruffin last Friday shows that Medlin changed his initial ruling and has found a debated protest petition regarding Jordan Lake is valid.
The memo (PDF) was requested by the Indy and other media outlets and released Wednesday evening with personnel and other information redacted. It shows that petitioners actually did include the required percentage of signatures, although Medlin initially said the petition did not include enough.
It's unclear what the next step for either the petitioners or the county is, but the findings will be the hot topic at a special county commissioners meeting tomorrow at 10 a.m. All or most of the discussion will likely occur behind closed doors. A meeting notice by the clerk to the Commissioners cited personnel privacy and a pending lawsuit against the county filed by Southern Durham Development as reasons the session is closed.
BACKGROUND: The controversy surrounds the status of a protest petition filed in the October rezoning of the Jordan Lake watershed by the Haw River Assembly, with the help of the Southern Environmental Law Center. Had the petition been valid, it would have required at least a 4-1 vote in favor of the rezoning, instead of the simple majority of 3 votes to 2. But the county said the petition was invalid.
The petitioners asked the county to revisit their verdict, even after commissioners voted to rezone the watershed. In an announcement Nov. 5, Siler said that he maintained the planning department’s ruling that the petition was invalid, and the problem was related to signatures. This memo indicates that Medlin has overruled findings by his own staff and County Attorney Lowell Siler.
Comments (4)
Showing 1-4 of 4
[...] when they heard the rezoning case Oct. 12. Whether the petition is truly valid is still debated. A memo released Wednesday shows Medlin believes the petition is valid, but Siler said he still questions [...]
like
dislike
I've heard Commissioner Brenda Howerton is out of town and unable to make the meeting tomorrow morning. I certainly hope this is not the case.
Why does the date on the memo say November 18, 2009? That's today's date. I thought the memo was initially written last Friday, November 13.
Finally the County has admitted its error, 45 days after the protest petition (the VALID protest petition) was filed. Is the County going to force citizens to go to court to remedy the string of errors in this case? Since even the County now considers the protest petition valid, the 3-2 vote on October 12 was insufficient to pass this rezoning. Since the County would lose any lawsuit (already having admitted error), why not simply admit that the vote stands, the rezoning fails, and save everyone a lot of time, money, and aggravation? Does anyone think that this case would ever go to court in the private sector?
Latest in Triangulator
-
In "Carrboro Commune" CVS takeover, no arrests, no SWAT team, plenty of controversy
A group of 20 anti-capitalist protesters occupied CVS-owned in property in downtown Carrboro for three hours Saturday night before walking out at the strong encouragement of town police and Carrboro Mayor Mark Chilton, who each told them they would be charged with breaking and entering if they did not leave.
- Feb 5, 2012
-
Breaking: Anti-capitalist occupiers say they've taken new Carrboro CVS
- Feb 4, 2012
-
Liberty Warehouse repairs unfinished; city could set new conditions, deadline next week
Greenfire Development would be subject to fines if the group is found at fault and fails to make repairs by a new deadline.
- Feb 2, 2012
- More »
Author Archives
-
UPDATE: Clerk's 31-percent raise was for professional certification
Durham commissioners have given raises to six top-level managers.
- Nov 14, 2011
-
751 South opponents begin appeals process
The attorney for Chancellor's Ridge HOA filed a notice of appeal Friday.
- Jan 20, 2012
- More »
