The House Wants to Turn Over Struggling Schools to Charter Operators | North Carolina | Indy Week
Pin It

The House Wants to Turn Over Struggling Schools to Charter Operators 

In recent years, cities such as Detroit and New Orleans, as well as the state of Tennessee, have moved toward replacing some public schools with privately run charters. Last Thursday, the North Carolina House took the first steps in that direction—even though critics say there's considerable evidence that these plans haven't worked elsewhere and won't work here, either.

House Bill 1080 cleared the House on a 60–49 vote, with three Democrats voting yes and a dozen Republicans voting no. The bill would place five low-achieving elementary schools in what's called an Achievement School District. The superintendent of the ASD, appointed by the State Board of Education, would then recommend a school-district operator to the board. This operator could be either nonprofit or for-profit; it just can't be the Department of Public Instruction. Teachers at these schools would then have to reapply to get their jobs back.

Marcus Brandon, a former House member who's now the executive director of the pro-reform group CarolinaCAN, says he supports HB 1080 because "there's around six hundred [underperforming] schools. There's no way DPI can help all of these schools." (Last year's budget loosened the definition of a "low-performing school," boosting the total to 581 from 348.)

Reformers argue that ASDs can be a particular boon to African-American students. Brandon and Representative Cecil Brockman, one of three Democrats to vote yes, point out that African-Americans are suffering the most in the current system.

"The status quo means two-thirds of people who look like me are failing," says Brockman. "If that was happening to white kids, we would do everything we could to help them." 

Something needs to be done, they say.

The theory underpinning the reform movement is that charter operators can run schools more effectively and with greater flexibility than the government—for example, they can fire bad teachers more easily than can traditional schools. 

But not everyone is on board. Kris Nordstrom, a former education policy analyst for the General Assembly, said in a letter to legislators last week that the bill "expands opportunities for corruption" and has "inadequate program evaluation."

"Even under the best conditions, there is no evidence that ASDs work," Nordstrom wrote. "[HB 1080] falls short of providing the best conditions."

Nordstrom's case rests with North Carolina's western neighbor. In 2012, Tennessee started an ASD program using federal Race to the Top funds. "The goal was to move schools from the bottom five percent to the top twenty-five percent," says Gary Rubinstein, a math teacher and education blogger. "They actually used the word 'catapult.' Now, five of the six original schools are in the bottom two and a half percent, and the other one that was supposed to break the twenty-five-percent barrier in four years is in the bottom sixth percentile."

Brandon brushes off Rubinstein's numbers. Schools in the Tennessee ASD "have seen double-digit gains in math and science," he says. (Rubinstein counters that those annual gains were "wiped out" the following year.)

Diane Ravitch, a former assistant secretary of education under President George H.W. Bush, says the success of charters is illusory. They merely look attractive, she says, because "the so-called high-performing charter schools choose their students carefully. What never works is for charter operators to take over a neighborhood school and turn it around."

In this case, she says, doing nothing would be better than enacting HB 1080.

"Doing nothing is not good, but doing something that's guaranteed to fail is worse," she says. "It's like if someone holds a knife to your back and says, 'Walk the plank,' staying where you are is a better idea, because at least then you're still alive."

Nordstrom says HB 1080 is worse than Tenessee's law in at least one way: Tennessee budgeted almost $50 million over four years for its ASD schools; HB 1080 provides no additional funding, implying that lawmakers think public schools will magically improve if turned into charters.

This faith in charters seems especially perplexing when you consider that North Carolina already has a successful turnaround model. According to a DPI report, the District and School Transformation program has brought 83 percent of the schools it worked with between 2010 and 2014 out of the bottom 5 percent of North Carolina schools. Despite that success, the budget the Senate passed last week calls for a $2.19 million cut to the DPI. Nordstrom says this turnaround program would "likely take the brunt of the Senate cuts," as it isn't required by law.

This article appeared in print with the headline "False Promises"

  • These operators can be for-profit or nonprofit. But they cannot be the Department of Public Instruction.

Comments

Showing 1-1 of 1

Add a comment

 
Subscribe to this thread:
Showing 1-1 of 1

Add a comment

INDY Week publishes all kinds of comments, but we don't publish everything.

  • Comments that are not contributing to the conversation will be removed.
  • Comments that include ad hominem attacks will also be removed.
  • Please do not copy and paste the full text of a press release.

Permitted HTML:
  • To create paragraphs in your comment, type <p> at the start of a paragraph and </p> at the end of each paragraph.
  • To create bold text, type <b>bolded text</b> (please note the closing tag, </b>).
  • To create italicized text, type <i>italicized text</i> (please note the closing tag, </i>).
  • Proper web addresses will automatically become links.

Latest in North Carolina



Twitter Activity

Most Recent Comments

Pay to play is alive and well in NC...only time voters matter is at election...Then the lies begin.

by Tony Dockery on What’s Standing Between Rural North Carolina and Reliable Internet Service? (North Carolina)

Jackson is just another republican creep who likes his slave labor...I am not surprised by this....This is how they govern......The …

by Tony Dockery on The U.S. Department of Labor Hits a State Senator’s Farm with a Conspicuously Small Fine (North Carolina)

Who are Jackson Farming Company's customers? Seems like this is the only place to apply pressure.

by Donald Chartier on The U.S. Department of Labor Hits a State Senator’s Farm with a Conspicuously Small Fine (North Carolina)

I know how many feel. I live between Benson and Highway 210. The only internet available, except satellite, is CenturyLink. …

by Kitty Hegemann 1 on What’s Standing Between Rural North Carolina and Reliable Internet Service? (North Carolina)

Missed Dr. LUEBKE today at UNC. I know he would have introduced the President of the United States as they …

by bethlalonde@yahoo.com on RIP Paul Luebke, a Progressive Icon (North Carolina)

Comments

Pay to play is alive and well in NC...only time voters matter is at election...Then the lies begin.

by Tony Dockery on What’s Standing Between Rural North Carolina and Reliable Internet Service? (North Carolina)

Jackson is just another republican creep who likes his slave labor...I am not surprised by this....This is how they govern......The …

by Tony Dockery on The U.S. Department of Labor Hits a State Senator’s Farm with a Conspicuously Small Fine (North Carolina)

Most Read

© 2016 Indy Week • 201 W. Main St., Suite 101, Durham, NC 27701 • phone 919-286-1972 • fax 919-286-4274
RSS Feeds | Powered by Foundation