Neighbors oppose new apartment complex near N.C. State University | Wake County | Indy Week
Pin It

Neighbors oppose new apartment complex near N.C. State University 

The five-story, 200-plus unit student apartment complex proposed for the intersection of Avent Ferry Road and Varsity Drive in Raleigh could permanently change the character of that neighborhood, and not necessarily for the better.

Last week, Raleigh's Comprehensive Planning Committee voted to hold a public hearing on a proposed rezoning of the 2.9 acres of land. As City Council member and committee chairman Russ Stephenson noted, several crucial questions about the long-term implications of the project remain unanswered.

Many neighbors oppose the proposed design and placement of the building, on the grounds that it will create a parking shortage and that it's inconsistent with the City's 2030 Comprehensive Plan.

As proposed by Dallas-based developer Phoenix Property Group, which has built cookie-cutter student housing complexes in college towns across the country, the building would feature what is known as an "urban limited frontage." In other words, the building would sit directly on the street.

Parking spaces are expensive for developers. In this case, Phoenix Property Group would have the financial advantage of providing less parking for the residents—0.68 spaces per bedroom—instead of the 0.75 or more that is typical at developments such as Wolf Village.

Lacy Reaves, the Raleigh-based attorney for Phoenix, told the committee that a study conducted by design consulting firm Kimley-Horn found the parking ratio to be adequate.

But Stephenson, chairman of the Comprehensive Planning Committee, says he and late City Councilor Thomas Crowder shared the concern that the urban frontage proposed for the building would detract from the look and feel of Avent Ferry Road.

Avent Ferry Road is a high-priority transit corridor where buses will run every 15 minutes during peak times. Yet it is also characterized by leafy streetscapes, lawns between the sidewalks and apartment buildings, plus shopping and entertainment centers like Mission Valley mall.

"Our view is that it makes sense to bring buildings in urbanized centers, like Mission Valley, up to the street," Stephenson says, "but it makes more sense to keep the tree-lined, green frontage in between those urban centers."

This kind of "green frontage," however, would mean designing a smaller building, a concept that the developer, whose profits hinge on filling the maximum number of apartments, has been unwilling to discuss.

The frontage that is ultimately agreed to in this case "will have implications for the character of many Raleigh thoroughfares that will redevelop over time with similar density increases," Stephenson says.

N.C. State University has a significant interest in the development, given that the meticulously landscaped entrance to Centennial Campus is diagonally across from the proposed building site, and university students could be the development's largest source of revenue

Stephenson predicts N.C. State University will push for green frontage as well, since it has invested so much in installing landscapes at the entrance to Centennial campus. The university also has an interest in seeing a different type of housing in the building. The four-bedroom, common living space typical of student housing (and that will be a feature of the seven-story student housing complex under construction on Hillsborough Street), is becoming obsolete. Undergraduate enrollment at N.C. State is declining—and will likely continue to do so—as the university shifts its focus to graduate education.

SOURCE: N.C. STATE UNIVERSITY OFFICE OF INSTITUTIONAL RESEARCH AND PLANNING WWW.OIRP.NCSU.EDU
  • SOURCE: N.C. STATE UNIVERSITY OFFICE OF INSTITUTIONAL RESEARCH AND PLANNING WWW.OIRP.NCSU.EDU

"The complete individual living type with its own kitchen and living area contained within one unit can serve students, young adults and seniors," Stephenson says. "But the rent-by-room with the common living space commonly marketed to undergrads will never appeal to a broader range of renters. That continues to be a concern."

Benson Kirkman, chairman of the Citizens Advisory Council West, says he and the other CAC members have different concerns about the project that he will discuss at the public hearing.

In September, city staff found the proposal consistent with the policy guiding documents, the 2030 Comprehensive Plan and Future Land Use Map, which state that in transit corridors like Avent Ferry, buildings can be up to five stories high. But Kirkman says that because of a hill on the lot, the building will appear to be six stories tall on one side, making the design inconsistent with the Comprehensive Plan.

"If you're going to exceed what those documents say, there ought to be clear justification for the need, or else you should be giving high-quality amenities with it," Kirkman says. "I don't see we are getting either. If they were doing exemplary landscape, that would at least alleviate it. But they are basically meeting the minimum standard."

Stephenson says that under the Unified Development Ordinance— a complete overhaul of Raleigh's zoning code—much is open to interpretation. "At this point, it seems unfair to the applicant to say we have to hold off because we don't like the way we wrote the rules," he said. "We'll see many cases where we'll scratch our heads and say, is this what we really meant? These early cases are case studies of the UDO, to understand how the language needs to be refined."

The City Council will set the date for the public hearing at its meeting this week.

This article appeared in print with the headline "Character flaws"

Tags:

Comments

Subscribe to this thread:

Add a comment

INDY Week publishes all kinds of comments, but we don't publish everything.

  • Comments that are not contributing to the conversation will be removed.
  • Comments that include ad hominem attacks will also be removed.
  • Please do not copy and paste the full text of a press release.

Permitted HTML:
  • To create paragraphs in your comment, type <p> at the start of a paragraph and </p> at the end of each paragraph.
  • To create bold text, type <b>bolded text</b> (please note the closing tag, </b>).
  • To create italicized text, type <i>italicized text</i> (please note the closing tag, </i>).
  • Proper web addresses will automatically become links.

Latest in Wake County



Twitter Activity

Most Recent Comments

A new label comes to mind: CHINO (Christian in Name Only). Most Christian sects instruct adherents to not surrender to …

by Bernard Baruch on Evangelicals in the Age of Trump (Or, Why I Was Called a ‘Jew-Boy’ at a Franklin Graham Rally) (Wake County)

Is it not lost on these people that Jesus Christ was a "Jew-boy"? I wouldn't be surprised if some of …

by PRGuy on Evangelicals in the Age of Trump (Or, Why I Was Called a ‘Jew-Boy’ at a Franklin Graham Rally) (Wake County)

Another one sided argument from the Indy. There are multiple bus stops in North Hills and north Raleigh, that contain …

by MX46 on Has Raleigh’s Bus System Been Left to Languish Because Many of Its Riders Are Poor and Black? (Wake County)

to elaborate on whatdoiknow's comment, the headline pertains to Durham as well. Transit in the triangle is run by a …

by where's the beef? on Has Raleigh’s Bus System Been Left to Languish Because Many of Its Riders Are Poor and Black? (Wake County)

Comments

A new label comes to mind: CHINO (Christian in Name Only). Most Christian sects instruct adherents to not surrender to …

by Bernard Baruch on Evangelicals in the Age of Trump (Or, Why I Was Called a ‘Jew-Boy’ at a Franklin Graham Rally) (Wake County)

Is it not lost on these people that Jesus Christ was a "Jew-boy"? I wouldn't be surprised if some of …

by PRGuy on Evangelicals in the Age of Trump (Or, Why I Was Called a ‘Jew-Boy’ at a Franklin Graham Rally) (Wake County)

Most Read

No recently-read stories.

Visit the archives…

© 2017 Indy Week • 201 W. Main St., Suite 101, Durham, NC 27701 • phone 919-286-1972 • fax 919-286-4274
RSS Feeds | Powered by Foundation