HomeNewsOrange County  }

Chapel Hill's incredible shrinking Halloween

Local traffic only

⇒ See also: "Make your own costume"

There won't be as many people dressed up as Eric Clapton for Halloween on Franklin Street this year. After midnight, they're going to shut the whole thing down. The street will be cleared, and you can then file into a bar, which will charge you a $5 cover, but you have to be inside before 1 a.m. You can't get in or come back in after that. That's if you are lucky enough to get downtown in the first place, and you probably won't be able to unless you live within walking distance of Franklin Street.

This is the second year of Homegrown Halloween in Chapel Hill, a locals-only version of what had become a statewide tradition that has been scaled down due to concerns about public safety. Mayor Kevin Foy rolled out this year's program, which has support from UNC Student Body President Jasmine Jones, along with downtown business owners.

"In order to manage this event, we discourage visitors to Halloween this year," Foy says in a town-produced YouTube video that concludes with him vanishing in a cloud of smoke to the sound of a creepy carnival organ.

"We don't want to see an uncomfortably large number of people squeezed into our small downtown as we have experienced in previous Halloweens. These large gatherings present many public safety concerns, including increased crime, crowd panic and fights, not to mention the seriousness of alcohol poisoning and gang violence. And this year we have the additional concern of H1N1 flu."

Police will set up alcohol checkpoints on the perimeter. Downtown-bound streets and lanes will close at 7 p.m. You can't find parking, you can't take a shuttle, you can't ride a charter buses. ("Charter buses entering the downtown Chapel Hill area will be directed by law enforcement officers to the outskirts of Town prior to dropping off any passengers," the town's Web site says.) And the town has also dashed any hopes of an extra hour of Halloween when daylight saving time kicks in at 2 a.m.: Chapel Hill joins Arizona and Hawaii in not setting back its clocks one hour. (Although, unlike the two states, Chapel Hill will reset its clocks after the event ends.)

The list of prohibitions could curb what had become an 80,000-person event in a town of 51,519. Last year, restrictions reduced the crowd to 35,000. This year, town officials are aiming for 15,000.

There were also fewer arrests last year, according to police: five compared with 13 in 2007. Alcohol overdose calls were down from 31 to 18.

A shrunken Halloween also costs less. In 2007, it cost $221,490 to host the event. Last year's curtailed version totaled $203,957.

DSI Comedy Theater Executive Producer and owner Zach Ward, a Chapel Hill native, finds the town's party pooping as a lost advertising opportunity. Ward can remember Halloweens from the mid-1990s that attracted revelers from Asheville and Charlotte. That made Chapel Hill "iconic," Ward said, adding that the large number of people and creative costumes made the town "hip and progressive."

He says last year's traffic restrictions hurt his Carrboro-based theater by keeping patrons who'd bought tickets online from parking at Carr Mill Mall. Now he worries what message leaders are sending.

"What the town doesn't understand, because all they see is a budget item for the police force and extra security and cleanup, is this bureaucratic separation from the word-of-mouth advertising the social event that Halloween represents," said Ward. "Instead of thinking about how can we capitalize on this event that's reached a peak in statewide interest, it's a small-town mentality of 'This is too big, we need to restrict it. We need to kick people out.' This is why Chapel Hill is losing business, storefronts are staying empty, and people choose not to live in Chapel Hill. People move to Durham."

8 COMMENTS

I just moved out of Chapel Hill and into Durham. Anyone know any good Halloween Parties?
by Bobby Chapel Hill 28 Oct 2009, 4:27pm Report this comment
Wait, so you're saying the cost only went down by ~$20,000? Seems like a lot of trouble for nothing, trying to cut down the size of the party.
by jsoucy Durham 28 Oct 2009, 5:41pm Report this comment
welcome to the police state! you can't even enjoy your holidays the way you choose, you get to abide by the rules, and be happy about it too, or they might find something else wrong with what you are doing.
by Jamesb33 NC , W-S 29 Oct 2009, 10:11am Report this comment
Oh, for Pete's sake, have your own party! The Hallowe'en scene on Franklin Street had gotten so overgrown and unpleasant that locals avoided it. I applaud the town's decision to scale the party back to something less expensive and less dangerous.

Zach, I'm disappointed in you. Your comments come across as mean-spirited sour grapes.

by MelodyLynn Chapel Hill 29 Oct 2009, 11:04am Report this comment
Disappointed in me? What am I, 10 years old?

I AM passionate about this issue. I believe the Town has made a GRAVE (pardon the Halloween pun) mistake by managing our growth this way. I think the article doesn't represent the FULL scope of my reasoning. And, appropriate for the article, Location Location Location. I am the only source quoted and My quotes (which I'll give an 85% accuracy based on context) are the Last words, making up 1/3 of the article. So it feels like I'm the only one speaking out. But from personal feedback on my Orange Politics post, I'm not the only person who seems to care about the issue.

http://orangepolitics.org/2009/10/how-the-townof-chapel-hill-stole-halloween

by Zach Ward Carrboro 30 Oct 2009, 2:26pm Report this comment
From your comments here and as quoted in the Indy, yeah, you sound about 10, and somewhat spoiled. I will check out your blog before I say anything stronger.
by MelodyLynn Chapel Hill 30 Oct 2009, 10:58pm Report this comment
Okay, Zach, I've read your blog. There were two or three people supporting your position, and a couple more asking questions, and one directly opposing you. This is not exactly a landslide of support for your PASSION about this matter.

I like DSI and I am prepared to like you, if you'll let me. Can we talk like reasonable people, please ?

Apparently I've lived in Chapel Hill and Carrboro longer than you have, and have worked for more businesses there, though I am not yet a geriatric looking for the Early Bird Specials as your snarkiest supporter suggests. I've also lived in Durham for a decade and wish it well. Enough credentials, or do you want to arm-wrestle for the honor of who knows our towns and their interests best?

Zach, have you been to Franklin Street on Hallowe'en night in the past few years? I have, and it was not fun. It was much too crowded and the crowd felt ugly, like a fight could break out any minute. There have been fights, and nothing but a large and wildly expensive police presence has kept them from erupting into a general melee. Many cases of alcohol poisoning have been rushed to the emergency room. Vandalism -- not cute stuff like egging and toilet paper, but broken windows and slashed tires and busted beer bottles all over the street -- has been common all over town, and there have been lots of muggings and assaults as the night became morning. In recent years I've lived on Macauley Street and Hillsborough Street and experienced the crap doesn't get reported to the police: drunks yelling at 4 am and vomiting and pissing in residents' yards, car windows broken, stuff like that. Do you live close enough to Franklin Street to have to put up with that?

At our last public festival that grew to attract people from all over the state someone was shot and killed. Do you think that's good for business?

I love Chapel Hill, I love and support local businesses, and I love Hallowe'en. I'd love to support and enjoy a Franklin Street celebration that works happily for all involved. Wouldn't you, Zach?

by MelodyLynn Chapel Hill 31 Oct 2009, 12:10am Report this comment
This move by Chapel Hill seems like an analogy for the general decline in Franklin Street over the years. Maybe the kids over at NCSU will get the Hillsborough Haunted Hike picking up steam.
by ncsu_grad Raleigh 31 Oct 2009, 10:50pm Report this comment
Add to the discussion
Post your comment
Add to the discussion
Post your comment
 
return to top