HomeNewsQ&A  }

Michael Weinstein

On evangelicals in the military

8 AUG 2007  •  by Fiona Morgan



Michael Weinstein
U.S. Air Force veteran Michael Weinstein says the American military is being undermined from within by fundamentalist Christians who are coercing soldiers into their brand of faith. A Republican who worked for President Ronald Reagan before becoming general counsel to Texas billionaire and presidential candidate Ross Perot, Weinstein is foremost a military man. His recent book, With God on Our Side: One Man's War Against an Evangelical Coup in America's Military, presents what he sees as a grave threat to the nation's security.

How many people have contacted your group, the Military Religious Freedom Foundation, with stories of being proselytized to by military commanders?

We've had just under 5,000 members of the U.S. Army, Marine Corps, Navy and Air Force. Of the troops who have come to us, including some civilians and veterans, roughly 96 percent of them are Christians themselves. The remaining 4 percent are the minority faiths, Jews, Hindus, Sikhs or atheists.

What sorts of stories do they tell you?

An army private from Fort Bragg contacted me when he was going through basic training. When he signed up, they asked him his religious denomination and he said Christian, but they identified him as not being fundamentalist enough Christian, and they punished him by putting 'none' on his dog tags. When he got to Afghanistan, the commander said that the blessings of the Lord Jesus would not be on the unit unless everyone were evangelical, and since he would not convert, this 20-year-old private would be responsible for the deaths and injuries the unit might suffer.

In another case, we caught a three-star general who ordered his staff to put together a PowerPoint presentation demonstrating the direct parallel between the Book of Revelation and all of our combat movements in Tikrit, Mosul, Fallujah, Sadr City and farther east in Afghanistan. We were able to stop it after it got to 2,500 troops.

What group inside the military is doing this?

What we're fighting here is a subset of evangelical Christianity that goes by a long name: pre-millennial dispensational reconstructionist dominionist fundamentalist evangelical Christianity. There's an organization for officers called the Officers Christian Fellowship, and for the enlisted folks called the Christian Military Fellowship. The first goal is a 'spiritually transformed' U.S. military. The second goal is [to be] ambassadors for Christ in uniform—by the way, if you check the last 2,000 years, that hasn't worked out too well. Thirdly, [they are] empowered by the Holy Spirit.

In the private sector this would last about three seconds. It would be a killer lawsuit under Title 7 of the U.S. Code. Those serving in the military have to give up many constitutional rights. 'Get the hell out of my face, sir or ma'am' is not an option for you if you're being even gently evangelized. Because they're second-class citizens by design, they're very vulnerable, and the military knows this.

When people come to you with these complaints, what do you do?

Our job is to kick ass and to take names. We lay down a withering field of fire and leave chest wounds on those who would bring constitutional darkness to our military. I usually call commanders and tell them that we're here and we're going public. But making phone calls and doing interviews is at best weed whacking; that keeps them at bay for only a short time. The best thing we can do is to go into federal court, which we will do in a few days with a massive federal lawsuit directly confronting this.

We are not trying to take anyone's religious faith away; we are simply saying you can't use the machinery of the state, the awesome power of our military, to force religion on your subordinates up and down the chain of command. Must we become the Christian Taliban to defeat this Taliban and Al Qaeda?

For more information, visit www.militaryreligiousfreedom.org.

9 COMMENTS

So much of what we see in these "hand wringing, oh its so... bad organizations," is usubstantiated complaints. People just need to show a little resolve, and look the person in the eye, smile and say, "No Thanks," I am not interested.
by yachtguy Raleigh 15 Aug 2007, 10:03am Report this comment
Please don't make light of Mr. Weinstein's concerns. He is speaking TRUTH. American citizenship is losing FREEDOM minute-by-minute. Get involved; help prevent the evil guised as "Jesus".
by GeniePooh (dancingdog@netscape.com) , UTAH 19 Aug 2007, 11:19am Report this comment
yachtguy: "So much of what we see in these 'hand wringing, oh its so... bad organizations,' is usubstantiated complaints." Really? Give an example. What, specifically, in this article would you say is untrue? "People just need to show a little resolve, and look the person in the eye, smile and say, 'No Thanks,' I am not interested." Read the article again. It's the military. They're superiors who are doing this and they don't appear to be swayed by "No thanks." How about if bible-thumpers just learn to live with people who don't share their beliefs? Would that be asking too much?
by chimpeach 19 Aug 2007, 4:01pm Report this comment
I just listened to Weinstein on TV giving a speech dated sometime in July. What he is espousing is manufactured in his own mind. Stop and ask the next military man / woman on the street if what Weinstein says is true. Don't just believe his rant, find out for yourself. For one, he is reinventing history, two, he does not know Christianity or the Christian Bible. What is very odd, is that many atheist Jews in this country hate Christians....what they don't realize is we are the only ones supporting them. And we will continue to do so...Why? Read the Bible.
by chance98 Carrboro 20 Aug 2007, 1:42am Report this comment
I also listened to MW's televised rant. He quoted several Bible versus; I forgot all but the last, which was Luke 19:40. MW claims it contains an order by Jesus to put non-believers to the sword -- a claim I easily found to be false. After listening to his diatribe, I believe this guy is spilling fantastic falsehoods.
by Ed , San Diego 20 Aug 2007, 2:35am Report this comment
> Chance98What is very odd, is that many atheist Jews in this country hate Christians....what they don't realize is we are the only ones supporting them. And we will continue to do so...Why? Read the Bible As a non believer I do not hate you but would like you to explain in what way do you support me?
by Peacfulseas 20 Aug 2007, 3:12am Report this comment
I recently had the pleasure of watching Mr. Weinstein on C-Span and was in awe. I was raised by a Jewish father from Philadelphia and a Catholic mother from Tennessee. I was exposed to both. Fortunately I turned out to be an atheist. My parents raised me to "treat others the way you would like to be treated". Religion is the root cause of most of the bloodshed and strife in this world. The fact that one of our fighter squadrons has a cross and three stars emblazened on the aircraft ought to tell you something. I guess when the rapture comes, the rest of us will just have to suffer in hell.
by wahoostew42 (wahoostew42@aol.com) , SE Florida 20 Aug 2007, 3:24pm Report this comment
I read the article: I saw him on book TV and I looked at the website. His material looks very well documented to me. He has articles posted from various reputable sources. I think Miki Weinstein is up holding the U.S Constitution in a brave way at great personal sacrifice. Most of us would not be willing to take the abuse and death threats he has been receiving as the result of his work.
by interested party Durham 20 Aug 2007, 4:20pm Report this comment
This is the first I've become aware of Michael Weinstein. I don't know the bible well at all and seeing that he has Joseph Wilson envolved in his foundation, makes it interesting for me to have an opinion on the subject. But I tend to lean towards what he is saying with agreement but with caution until I do some of my own basic research. Having said that, my belief of Bush all along was that even before reading what he stood for, I for some reason never trusted him and didn't vote for Bush either. Michael does present a compelling view because I do believe that the media is lazy and this Iraq war is illegal and immoral. Everyone has the right to be what ever they are religiously. So if what Weinstein is saying is true on any level where young military officers are being coerced evangelically, this goes against the division of church and state and thus undermines the reason for it as layed out in our constitution. All we have that holds our country and republic in tact is not only the constitution but the hope that people do not become to apathetic when it comes to enforcing it. Dave Demoise
by demoisedrawings , North east 22 Aug 2007, 12:37pm Report this comment
Add to the discussion
Post your comment
Add to the discussion
Post your comment
 
return to top